Skip to contents

bones (development version)

  • A wrapped fill output, such as DT::DTOutput(), outside a fill layout now keeps its own height. Before, the wrapper made DT hold the table at 400px, and the rows spilled over the next element.

bones 0.2.0

CRAN release: 2026-11-13

Breaking changes

  • withBones() now shows a calm panel when an output fails. After a good load, it keeps the old content dimmed with a banner. This is on by default and changes the error display on upgrade. Use bones_defaults(error = FALSE) to keep the error text of Shiny. Silent req() errors and validate() messages keep their usual behaviour (#19).
  • A bad type, animation or shape now gives a clear error with a hint for a near miss. Only exact names are accepted: a short form such as type = "pi" is now an error that says Did you mean "pie"? (#24).
  • withBones() and bones_skeleton() warn about unused shape arguments. A new warning may appear in code that passed an unused argument. bones_auto() does not give these warnings (#25).

New features

  • An output learns the shape of its content. After a load, the browser stores the place of each line of text, image and card. On the next visit, the skeleton has that shape in place of a guess from the type of the output. It is on by default. It applies only when you do not give type, rows, cols, lines, n or skeleton, and not to charts. A stored shape is used only at almost the same width, and it holds only numbers, never text. Turn it off with withBones(learn = FALSE) or bones_defaults(learn = FALSE).
  • bones_error() builds an error panel with a custom message. Error detail is off by default; use it only for development. Messages from safeError() still show when detail is off (#19).
  • withBones(retry = "id") adds a Try again button to the error panel (#20).
  • withBones(hold = "refresh") shows the skeleton when an input changes. JavaScript can also use Bones.hold(el) and Bones.release(el) (#44).
  • withBones() gains speed and color, for one output. bones_defaults() still sets them for the whole session.
  • The colours can be set in CSS, with or without Bootstrap. --bones-color, --bones-radius and the other properties now work on :root and on a container. Two new properties, --bones-text and --bones-surface, set the colours that the others are made from. With no Bootstrap 5 theme, the skeleton takes the text colour of the page, not a fixed grey.
  • bones_shapes() lists all valid shapes, or the shapes in the basic, chart or table group (#26). bones_animations() lists the valid animations.
  • bones works under a strict Content-Security-Policy, such as style-src 'self' with no 'unsafe-inline'. It writes no style attribute any more, which such a policy blocks. The sizes, positions and colours of a skeleton go in a data-bones-style attribute, and a script in bones sets them in the browser. The look does not change. A style attribute that Shiny or a widget writes on the output itself, such as the height of plotOutput(), is not from bones and is left as it is.

Minor improvements and bug fixes

  • withBones() reserves the natural height of a custom skeleton when no height is given. An explicit learn = TRUE replaces it with the learned content shape on later visits. Custom skeletons keep their look by default (#43).
  • withBones() shows session options in its defaults. bones_defaults() with no arguments returns current values. Call it before you build the UI, when the options are read (#28).
  • bones_auto() gives a short error and a hint for a misspelt argument name (#29).
  • With stale = FALSE, old content stays visible until the skeleton appears. Fast recalculations no longer flash a blank box (#42).

bones 0.1.1

CRAN release: 2026-10-16

First release.

  • withBones() puts a placeholder around a Shiny output. The placeholder has the shape of the content, and the shape comes from the class of the output.
  • The placeholder keeps the height of the output until the content arrives, so the page does not move. The content then sets the height, so no gap stays under content that is shorter than the estimate.
  • The skeleton shows on the first load only. When the output calculates again, the old content stays on the screen, dimmed. Set stale = FALSE to show the skeleton again instead.
  • All outputs show a recalculation at the same time, also when several outputs use one slow reactive and Shiny calculates them one after the other.
  • bones_skeleton() makes a placeholder on its own, for use where there is no Shiny output. It takes space in its container, and brings its stylesheet, its animation and its colours.
  • A chart can have the shape of its kind: type = "bar", "line", "area", "scatter", "histogram", "pie" or "heatmap". A plotOutput() with no type gets the bar shape, as before.
  • A visualisation widget gets the shape of its kind, with no type. New shapes: "map" (leaflet, tmap, mapview, mapdeck, mapgl, googleway, threejs globe), "network" (visNetwork, DiagrammeR, networkD3, collapsibleTree), "timeline" (timevis) and "wordcloud" (wordcloud2). dygraphs gets "line". ggiraph and other widgets that draw any chart keep the bar shape.
  • A table from DT, reactable, gt or rhandsontable gets a shape that copies that package, with no type: for example the search box and the pages of DT, or the title and the spanner of gt. The space kept for each one was measured in a browser. gt is found from gt 1.0.0; with an older gt, give type = "gt".
  • The real height of the content is remembered. When the content arrives, the browser stores its height, and on the next visit the placeholder keeps that height in place of the estimate, so the page does not move. Only an estimated height is stored, per page and per output id, and it is used only at almost the same width. Turn it off with remember = FALSE.
  • A fast load does not flicker. The skeleton, and the dimming of old content, appear only after delay (300 ms), so a load that ends sooner shows nothing. Once visible, they stay for at least min_time (500 ms). Both are arguments of withBones() and bones_defaults().
  • The colours come from the theme of the page: the text colour of the bslib theme, made faint. A skeleton thus takes the tint of a branded theme, and turns light in a dark theme or a dark part of a page, with no configuration. The corners follow the rounding of the theme. With no Bootstrap 5 theme, the colours are neutral greys.
  • bones_defaults() sets the colours, the corner radius, the animation and the speed for the session. A colour set there is stronger than the theme.
  • The arguments are checked, and a bad value gives a message that names the argument. height works as in Shiny, so a number is pixels.
  • There is no animation for users who ask their system to reduce motion.
  • The demo is a tour, with a tab for charts, tables, text and cards, and maps and networks. The sidebar sets the load time, stale, the animation and the dark mode, so you can see each option at work.
  • A plotly, echarts4r or highcharter output finds the kind of its chart by itself. When the first value arrives, bones reads the kind of the series, and the next loads show that shape. A box plot or another kind with no shape keeps the bar shape. With remember, the kind is stored in the browser, so the first skeleton of the next visit has the right shape too. A type that you give always wins.
  • bones_auto() puts each Shiny output in a UI in withBones(), so an app gets skeletons with one call. It keeps an output that is already wrapped, and leaves alone an inline output and the ids in exclude. Other arguments go to each wrapper. A bslib page keeps its class and its theme.
  • Two more animations: "cascade", where each bar, cell or line lights up a little after the one before, and "sweep", where one band of light crosses the whole placeholder. Both stop for users who ask to reduce motion.
  • withBones(skeleton = ) takes a placeholder of your own, for a layout that no built-in shape fits. Build it from bones_block(), a grey block with the colours and the animation of bones, and any tags around it. It waits for delay, keeps the space of the content, and keeps stale content, as a built-in shape does.
  • A wrapped output that fills its container in a fillable bslib layout, such as a plot in a card, still fills it: the wrapper passes the fill on. This needs htmltools 0.5.4 or newer.